I was born on the prairies, where the wind blew free and there was nothing to break the light of the sun. I was born where there were no enclosures. [GERONIMO]
Friday, September 2, 2011
Malaysia's international standing on refugee handling sucks, no thanks to UMNO
Aussie court ruling ends ‘international charade’
Global rights movement Amnesty International (AI) today lauded an Australian High Court decision ‘stopping’ a controversial refugee swap deal between Australia and Malaysia.
Describing the decision as “a landmark victory for human rights”, Amnesty’s refugee spokesman Graham Thom said AI had consistently warned the Australian government that Malaysia was a dangerous destination for asylum seekers.
He said sending ‘vulnerable’ people to Malaysia violated Australia’s obligations under international laws.
“Amnesty International is delighted that the High Court has prevented this outrageous, politically-motivated scheme from going ahead.
“Malaysia is clearly not a safe destination for refugees and asylum seekers.
“The government should have not contemplated outsourcing Australia’s refugee protection obligations to a country which regularly canes, detains and abuses asylum seekers, and which refuses to sign the UN Refugee Convention,” said Thom in a statement released by Amnesty in the United States.
On Aug 31, Australia’s High Court ruled that the Australia-Malaysia refugee swap as illegal.
The court noted that Malaysia provided no legal guarantees to protect the rights of asylum seekers.
‘Common sense has prevailed’ The decision has been largely applauded by activists on both sides who felt that Malaysia as a non-signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention was the least suitable place to dump refugees.
Of particular concern to many was the fact that children were among the many refugees under the swap deal.
The decision, Thom said, vindicated Amnesty’s grave concerns that unaccompanied children would be at particular risk if removed to Malaysia.
“As the legal guardian of the unaccompanied minors, the Immigration Minister must act in the children’s best interests.
“Sending them to Malaysia is in blatant breach of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.”
“Now that the High Court has put an end to this sorry saga, it’s time for common sense to prevail,” added Thom.
“Australia should treat all asylum seekers equally, regardless of whether they come by boat or by plane.
“All asylum seekers should be processed on the mainland in accordance with our obligations under the UN Refugee Convention,” he said.
‘International charade’ Meanwhile Malaysia’s opposition party DAP has also welcomed the Australian High Court decision
Bukit Bendera parliamentarian Liew Chin Tong said the ruling had put a stop to “an international charade.”
“It has also highlighted the Malaysian government’s failure to be a signatory to the Refugee Convention, which has been ratified by 147 countries around the world.
“The arrangement between Australia and Malaysia on transfer and resettlement is akin to two sovereign governments engaging in trading humans for money.
“The 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees is the key legal document in defining who is a refugee, their rights and the legal obligations of states towards refugees. The 1967 Protocol removed geographical and temporal restrictions from the Convention,” he said.
Liew added that with the ruling, Malaysia, as a responsible member of the international community guided by ethics and principles, should not pursue the refugee swap deal any further.
“It should ratify the Refugee Convention immediately,” he said.
I believe that UMNO thinks that the whole world is stupid. If our own citizens can be treated with disdain i.e. discriminated, marginalised, killed while in custody and the uncouth treatment on the Bersih protesters, what hope do these refugees have in surviving here? Again, doubts are raised on, why swap 4,000 non-Muslims refugees for 800 Muslims? If they are concerned about human trafficking, why not accept a sizeable number irrespective of the religion? It is even less comforting to note what Mahathir said at the height of the Vietnamese boat refugees in the late 70s? Shoot them out of the water! Although he tried to correct that statement in later years, it however left a bad taste with everyone.